Ten years ago, a lung specialist told a woman I know:
"You have Alpha-1 Antitrypsin Deficiency. There's no cure. You have about five years to live."
I know a LOT of doctors. I like and respect most of them. I have a decent regard for the work involved in getting an MD degree, the basic ability required to achieve it, the difficult and stressful work that most doctors do.
But THAT doctor, when he made THAT statement, was being an ass, an idiot, a fool, an ignoramus. Oh, yes: a fake, too. He knew next to nothing about Alpha-1, and he was too arrogant to admit it.
How DARE he tell that woman how long she had to live? Would HE want to be told he had five years to live? By some jerk who didn't know what he was talking about -- but pretended he did?
The doctor was full of crap. Let me count just a few of the ways.
1. The doctor knew next to nothing about Alpha-1. It's always the guys who don't know much about it who read a little bit in their medical reference book, then say wildly inaccurate things that cause their patients the most fear and heartache.
2. The doc had no way of knowing how long the woman had to live.
3. Even if the doc had been a world-class expert in Alpha-1, he STILL wouldn't have known how long the woman had to live. Of course a true expert would never pretend he could make an accurate prediction.
4. That ignorant fool of a doctor had a lot of company. I've heard the story all too often: the doctor gives an Alpha this scary-sounding diagnosis, then says, "You only have about five years to live."
For some reason, five years seems to be a popular estimate, but I hear two years is common as well.
So I asked a real world-class Alpha specialist if there's any medical evidence to support that five-years-to-live estimate. Surprise: There is none.